There was one athlete on the team, I'll call him Rick, who was really terrible. If giftedness is just another way of saying special, then that alone isn't a good enough argument. If your children truly are gifted, don't tell them. Why suggest parents have an impartial advisor look into their child's gift, but then the parents keep it secret? For example, National Football League teams spend millions of dollars each year in an effort to identify which college players will become superstars, yet these efforts often go for naught. In an ideal world, allowances would be made for each child so that everyone could reach their full potential. :->. Ryan Leaf was considered "a sure thing" as the number-two pick in the 1998 draft by the San Diego Chargers and yet he was a flop from the start and is now out of professional football. Though there are certainly some valid tests of intellectual ability, the reality is that we are quite bad at predicting who will be successful in the long run, primarily because, as the reserach shows, innate ability becomes less predictive of future performance the only people get. Even as a rhetorical device, it is unfair to the conversation. Perfectionism leads gifted kids to push themselves unreasonably - quite the opposite of coasting on their talent. Did they visit this place? You'd be better off wrapping up an antique. Yes, children can gain more knowledge and skills, but they can't become more talented. Your favorite cleaning tools and sprays might put a smile on your face, but your friends and family are going to wonder what you're really trying to say if they were to open them as a gift. And, this is why we must identify and talk about giftedness. Knowing they're gifted gives us the opportunity to explore their options in a different way. Perhaps that is my own shortcoming and I'm not trying to blame anybody, nor am I trying to sound arrogant. Although the example is physical, it is nevertheless a classic example of the interaction between parent and intellectually gifted child: the child is pursuing a goal with passionate intensity, and the parent is facilitating to the best of their ability - often far beyond the parent's threshold of patience and interest. In the end, my parents prevailed but it was a pyrrhic victory. They can be ironic and fun for parties, but they can also make horrible gifts. 10 Major Gift-Giving Mistakes to Never Make, You Said It: The Best Gift You've Ever Received, 10 of the Craziest Gifts Ever Given to a Kid, The Cleaning Products You Should Never Mix, 32 Incredible Gifts That Give to Those in Need. Yet we're lousy at predicting who becomes successful in school, sports, the arts, or any other achievement area. Do I want the raw, gifted talent... or do I want the hard-working person? Try one of these 15 thoughtful Christmas gifts under $30 instead ». Dr. Taylor makes a meaningful and valuable argument about the value of hard work, but unfortunately does so in a way that reinforces many of society's negative preconceptions about giftedness. The key is to help them understand what giftedness really means (e.g., a head start, a great opportunity) as opposed to what our culture tells kids about being gifted (e.g., no effort required, guaranteed success). With almost complete unanimity, children say they would rather be gifted. Because everything comes so easily to them, many never learn the skills—hard work, persistence, patience, perseverance, discipline—that will enable them to become truly successful. Dr. Taylor said so. It's not about knowing. I say keep them in the grade they are at, just because you pass a test don't mean you have learned all there is on that grade level. The ones that prefer to sit still and read. Remember, though not all gifted children are alike, so not every gifted child will have all of these behaviors. Our culture places a tremendous burden on gifted children to get 100% every time. We tend to be the calmest kids. And I paid the price for it when intelligent people such as yourself read it. I want to offer a few additional thoughts. It didn't come easy. Nevertheless, she was crying in frustration - not pain - when I made her stop because of injury. I think you might want to reassess if it is at all clear in the original article that you were being facetious. I recommend that you erase the word potential from your vocabulary as well. To me there is no such thing as "dumb", just improperly or insufficiently educated (or uneducated, in the case of children living in poorer parts of the world without access to a good education, sadly. (If I were, that would include me, since my father's side of the family appears prone to anxiety!). Whoops, should have looked before I commented. How many times have you heard "Tiger Woods was born to play golf," or "Sarah Chang was destined to be a brilliant violinist"? This is differentiation, grade skipping and acceleration are so vital especially for highly and profoundly gifted kids. Skip the store-bought, boxed cakes and opt for literally any other baked good. You *BELIEVE* the stereotypes - and therefore to challenge them effectively becomes impossible. I would be quite interested to see more on this subject (developing the habits of hard work) and less on the non-value of giftedness. I love your comment about "how to be holistic about all of my traits." Not to mention, embarrassing as it is to admit, I find it difficult to ask for help with stuff. Amazon predicts these will be the hottest toys this year ». My son got a 95 after studying all day on a Sunday. If your children aren't gifted, that's fine too, because they may have talents that haven't yet been discovered and they can still do their best and become successful.